‘He used Pornhub as the gun’
Court filings reveal how one of the world’s largest porn companies allowed child sexual abuse and nonconsensual videos to spread, even after victims and police flagged them.
Late on a Tuesday night in September 2019, Tina’s phone pinged with a message. The subject line read, in part, “fuck you slut!!!!!” The message contained a link to Pornhub, the world’s most popular porn site.
At the time, Tina — who spoke to the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists on the condition that her last name not be used — had recently ended a relationship with an abusive boyfriend. When she had tried to break up with him months earlier, Tina said he coerced her into making sexually explicit videos. It was his way, she told ICIJ, of controlling her.
Tina’s ex-boyfriend had now published those videos on Pornhub. It was the beginning of a months-long campaign of harassment and death threats: He posted videos and photos of her more than 100 times on Pornhub, according to emails reviewed by ICIJ, using accounts created in her name and including her address, phone number and employer.
He also posted photographs of her underage daughters at the beach in bikinis, along with their names and contact information. He emailed one daughter with a link to the videos of Tina and told her to ask her mother “why she put you all in danger from weirdos all over the country.”
“My ex wanted to kill me,” Tina said. “And he used Pornhub as the gun.”
Pornhub’s owner, the Montreal-based company Aylo, runs some of the world’s most popular websites. Its network of over 100 sites — including Pornhub, YouPorn and RedTube — attracts more than 100 million visits every day and has generated hundreds of millions of dollars in annual revenue, according to the most recent available data.
Aylo’s profits were built in part on some of the most heinous material on the internet. At the time of Tina’s abuse in September 2019, anyone could create a free account on Pornhub and upload videos; Pornhub did not require verification of the uploader’s identity.
Aylo has long employed moderators, whose job includes the identification of instances of sex trafficking, as well as photos and videos of minors. But the company was overwhelmed by the deluge of content: More than 6.8 million videos were uploaded to Pornhub in 2019; the company bragged in its 2019 “year in review” that if a viewer started watching all of them in 1850, they would still be watching.
Tina is just one of the many individuals victimized on the company’s websites. In 2020, Aylo removed more than 347,000 videos for nonconsensual content, according to a complaint filed by the Federal Trade Commission and the state of Utah. Aylo has made numerous changes since then — such as verifying the identity of uploaders — but its own reports show that potentially abusive and exploitative content continues to be published on Pornhub.
Many of these videos were hiding in plain sight. In 2019, just as Tina’s ex-boyfriend was using coerced sex videos to blackmail her into remaining in their relationship, Aylo identified over 30,000 videos associated with the word “blackmail.” More than half a million videos were associated with the term “forced.”
Aylo allowed users to continue posting videos with these terms because, in the words of one employee in an email to a colleague, they were used frequently in BDSM and staged blackmail videos, and thus “relatively compliant” with the company’s terms of service (Pornhub told ICIJ that “blackmail” and “forced” are currently banned on all Aylo platforms).
This exchange was included in court documents reviewed by ICIJ from a class-action lawsuit against Aylo filed in Alabama in February 2021. The documents, which were supposed to be sealed, inadvertently became publicly accessible on the court’s electronic docket for eight months because of a filing error. A judge recently granted preliminary approval to a settlement agreement in that case and a related California class action. As part of the settlement, Aylo committed to the single largest known payout to victims in the company’s history.
Aylo does not want the world to see what these records reveal about its business practices. After ICIJ approached the company for comment for this article, Aylo asked a federal judge in Alabama to bar ICIJ from publishing “any information learned or derived from” the documents. This extraordinary request threatened to muzzle ICIJ’s reporting on Aylo’s behavior, far beyond the contents of the court filings.
The judge rejected Aylo’s motion to prevent ICIJ from publishing an article based on the records.
The documents not only reveal details about how Aylo allowed the publication of nonconsensual sex videos like Tina’s, but also how its platforms hosted tens of thousands of videos and images of potential child sexual abuse material (CSAM). In an internal email, Aylo’s child safety manager acknowledged that the company removed 20,357 pieces of content as potential CSAM in 2020 alone. Aylo only began requiring uploaders to verify their identities in December 2020, so these removals reflect a period when many uploaders were still unverified.
One analysis produced by the U.K.-based Internet Watch Foundation released in these documents found five instances of CSAM featuring a child between 3 and 6 years old, and 25 instances of CSAM featuring a child between 7 and 10 from 2017 through 2019.
In a statement, Pornhub told ICIJ that CSAM and non-consensual content “is not tolerated” on Aylo’s sites, and that the company “recognize[s] the serious harm it causes the people depicted.” It said it removes videos as potential CSAM “when there is any doubt” that an individual is an adult. It also stated that Aylo “is committed to the safety and integrity of its platforms,” and that the company “will continue to invest in robust safeguards and to work with law enforcement to prevent online abuse and hold bad actors accountable.”
The documents, which largely concern abusive content posted in 2020 and earlier, show a company that often fell short of those standards. Even notification from law enforcement of CSAM on the company’s sites was no guarantee that the illegal content would be promptly removed. In one instance, according to a deposition of an Aylo employee included in the court filings, Pornhub kept a video featuring the abuse of a 12-year-old boy online for more than a month after being informed of it by an Alabama law enforcement special agent.
In an internal email, an Aylo employee wrote that there was a request in this case “NOT to remove the content.” A separate civil complaint filed by the abused boy’s mother alleged that law enforcement officers informed Aylo that the illegal content was on its site three times, over a period of multiple weeks, and requested that it be removed.
Other CSAM videos remained on the site for years. And when discovered, some Aylo employees viewed their presence more with bemusement than horror.
“You guys want to laugh,” one moderator wrote to colleagues in 2020, as the company tested new CSAM detection software. “It caught a cp [child pornography] video from 2009 … a full on cp video on the site for 11 yrs.”
Another employee described a former moderator as “almost blind,” and wrote that he “put through so much stuff loool.”
Pornhub’s victims described a cycle of trauma as they struggled to scrub their name and images from the internet. Tina said Pornhub was too slow to take down the accounts with her name and contact information. And when they were finally removed, she said, her ex-boyfriend would simply create a new account and post the videos again.
The Pornhub email address used by victims to submit takedown requests included an automated response stating that an employee would respond within two days. Perversely, the response also promoted a program enabling users to “make money from your homemade videos.”
Tina would often realize the videos had been reposted because men would deluge her with lewd calls. Pornhub notified Tina that it “fingerprinted” her videos, a technology that generates a unique digital signature of a video to prevent its reupload, seven months after she first notified the company of them, according to emails reviewed by ICIJ.
Even before Tina’s videos first appeared, Pornhub had publicly touted its “state-of-the-art” fingerprinting technology to prevent revenge porn from being reuploaded. As Tina was struggling frantically to get her videos offline, Pornhub’s executives formulated a policy that called for victims of revenge porn to be offered fingerprinting services. But Tina says Pornhub did not tell her that her videos had been fingerprinted until she sent an all-caps email notifying the company that she was a crime victim. “DO BETTER PORNHUB!!!!,” the email read.
But Tina’s nightmare was still not over. Even after Pornhub removed the videos, it would sometimes leave the page on which they resided that included her personal information, emails reviewed by ICIJ showed. To this day, a Google search of her name brings up Pornhub results, though not the videos themselves ; other porn sites also include her address at the time.
Tina eventually moved to a new city because she no longer felt safe in her neighborhood. She became anxious if someone looked at her too long or when she was around large groups of men. She wasn’t in a relationship for years.
“I wish I had been raped physically because then it would only have been once,” she said. The reuploading of the videos, the online comments about her body by strangers, the lewd calls, she said, “felt like a rape every single time.”
‘We need more staff’
The abusive content on Aylo’s sites led some employees to believe that they were witnessing the company’s demise. “It’s over,” one wrote in 2020. “We’re fucked.”
Six years later, Aylo remains one of the giants of the online pornography industry. It has weathered a wave of legal challenges through settlements with its antagonists. It signed a deferred prosecution agreement with the Justice Department in which it agreed to pay the U.S. government a penalty of just under $2 million. It also resolved the lawsuit filed by the FTC and Utah for $5 million and reached confidential settlements with dozens of victims that likely cost millions more.
Richard Zitrin, a legal ethics scholar at the University of California College of the Law in San Francisco, told ICIJ that firms accused of harming the public often opt to resolve allegations behind closed doors rather than publicly litigate their conduct. “It is common practice for companies that want to hide damaging information,” he said.
In August, Aylo publicly disclosed that it had agreed to resolve the Alabama class-action lawsuit, as well as a similar case in California. The proposed settlement, which received preliminary approval from a judge on Nov. 9, commits Aylo to paying $120 million into a fund to compensate people who can establish that sexually explicit content of them appeared on Aylo’s websites when they were under 18. Aylo did not admit to any wrongdoing as part of the settlement, which still must receive final approval from the court after a February hearing.
As part of the settlement, Aylo agreed to strengthen its policies to verify the age and identity of individuals depicted on its sites. The agreement would also commit the company to new policies and technological safeguards to prevent the spread of CSAM, and subject the company to external monitoring over the next five years. Pornhub told ICIJ that these commitments “build on existing processes across Aylo platforms.”
Aylo made major changes in 2020, when it banned uploads from unverified users, removed up to 10 million videos from individuals whose age and identity it could not confirm, and stopped allowing downloads of most content. It also adopted technology used by YouTube and Facebook to identify child sexual abuse.
Still, those changes were not enough to stop potentially illegal content from appearing on Aylo’s sites. In 2025, Pornhub removed nearly 1,000 videos of potential CSAM or non-consensual material that had been viewed by visitors, according to the company’s transparency reports.
Laila Mickelwait, CEO of the anti-trafficking organization Justice Defense Fund and a longtime advocate for shutting down Pornhub, told ICIJ that even with the settlement, the litigation facing Aylo “is far from over.”
Mickelwait pointed to an array of lawsuits filed against the company in the United States on behalf of numerous alleged victims of child abuse and trafficking, as well as legal challenges in Canada. She said the documents from the Alabama class-action lawsuit “demonstrate the depth of Pornhub’s knowledge and complicity and will hopefully serve as critical evidence for a full criminal prosecution of Pornhub and its owners.”
Under the terms of the settlement agreement, the sheer number of underage victims means the individual payouts would be comparatively modest. The settlement administrator submitted two scenarios to the court: a low-end estimate in which the fund would pay 2,000 individuals, and a high-end estimate in which it would pay 4,000 people.
About $50 million would pay lawyers’ fees and other expenses. That means each victim would receive roughly $17,000 to $35,000 paid out over seven years, under the scenarios submitted by the administrator.
Despite its many tangible benefits, the deal comes at a cost. This settlement, like the ones that came before it, prevented a full public understanding of Aylo’s actions.
[The litigation facing Aylo] is far from over. — Laila Mickelwait, Justice Defense Fund CEO
Had the Alabama case gone to trial, the victims’ lawyers could have used the documents obtained during discovery to build their case.
They could have quoted, for example, the Aylo executive who argued against banning the term “young girl,” writing that he didn’t think “it implies underage in the same way as young boy.” Or they could have referred to the email of another employee, who wrote that he “would be concerned for user experience” if the company banned the word “teen,” one of its most popular searches worldwide.
Pornhub told ICIJ that “young girl” and “young boy” are currently both banned “and cannot be used in titles, tags, or searches” on Aylo’s sites. It did not answer a question about whether “teen” was banned.
The lawyers also could have described Aylo’s chronically understaffed moderation teams. “We need more staff,” one moderator wrote. “Tell those fucks to spend 90k per yr on 3 peopels salary.”
Finally, they could have painted a picture of Aylo’s alleged efforts to squelch a record of its executives’ discussions of illegal content on its sites. The company fired its trust and safety manager, Ashley Walling, after it discovered that she had recorded a Zoom meeting involving the CEO and other top executives in which they discussed CSAM, Walling claimed in a deposition included in the court documents. After learning of the recording, Aylo suspended her employment, brought in a private investigator, and asked that she hand over her phone and provide its passwords, Walling claimed.
Aylo said it does not comment on individual personnel matters, but “firmly reject[s] any suggestion that an employee has been disciplined or dismissed for raising concerns about CSAM.”
Walling said in the deposition that she did not remember why she recorded the Zoom call. She also refused to answer a question about the details of the meeting discussing CSAM, following instructions from Aylo’s attorneys not to answer.
“They asked me questions as to why I would have taken the recording, what was my state of mind,” Walling said. “Then I was terminated.”
The ‘internet iceberg’
In 2023, Aylo was sold to the Canada-based private equity firm Ethical Capital Partners. The firm’s co-founding partner, Solomon Friedman, a criminal defense attorney and ordained rabbi, has spoken about taking the online porn industry “from the gray into the light.”
Such rhetoric aside, many of the same figures who had previously guided Aylo’s operations remained in senior positions after the purchase. They include Karim El Marazi, lead executive officer; Anthony Penhale, chief legal officer; Matt Kilicci, vice president of trust and safety; Anis Baba, head of European operations; and Andreas Ignatiou, head of the firm’s Cyprus-based moderation team — who were all identified as Aylo employees after the 2023 sale in public records or court documents. According to their LinkedIn profiles, they continue to work for the company to this day.
“Reform depends on people who know the platforms, the technology, and the regulatory landscape,” Pornhub told ICIJ in a statement. “Many long-serving employees have been central to building and running Aylo’s trust and safety programs, and they continue that work under new ownership and new leadership priorities.”
The documents in the Alabama case also cast doubt on the company’s assurances about its methods to prevent the spread of CSAM. In a 2020 blog post, for example, the company touted its use of fingerprinting technology, which meant that any CSAM videos it found “cannot be re-uploaded,” it wrote.
But a few months before that blog post was published, Aylo executives drafted a policy covering how to respond when law enforcement officers report the existence of CSAM to the company. Aylo would not “communicate fingerprinting action back to complainant unless asked,” the document stated, “because we do not want to be seen as offering a guarantee” that the content would not reappear. This was necessary because the contractor providing fingerprinting services “has its limitations.”
Aylo’s then-CEO also told a Canadian parliamentary committee that requiring uploaders to provide government-issued identification to verify their age and identity meant that “every piece of content on our websites can be traced back to its uploader.” But the court documents show that the contractor tasked to verify the IDs of uploaders warned Aylo that “sophisticated and determined fraudsters” could defeat its technology.
This requirement would also not have thwarted some of the previous abusers mentioned in the Alabama court documents. The person who abused the Jane Doe at the center of the Alabama class-action lawsuit was verified. The abuser who victimized the 12-year-old boy was not only verified but allegedly sold videos of the abuse for $5 to $20 through Pornhub’s revenue-sharing program, according to the civil complaint filed by the boy’s mother. Some of the videos remained for sale for almost seven months and attracted more than 180,000 views and 1,100 subscribers — meaning that Aylo profited directly from the abuse, the complaint alleges.
The internet is terrestrial. It’s people going into buildings every day and making decisions. — Justine Li, cyber exploitation victims’ advocate
Tina and other victims described to ICIJ obsessively searching their names on Google, agonizing over the continued presence of their abuse online. For them, one of the most important interventions is the erasure of their names and intimate images from the internet. But it is often relief that remains out of reach.
Justine Li, a sex trafficking survivor herself, launched the National Center for Victims of Internet and Cyber Exploitation last year to offer victims a single portal through which they can manage takedown requests.
Li’s strategy is to target what she calls the “internet iceberg.” At the top are the operators of the sites that host the illegal content. Below the surface are other companies — hosting providers, payment processors and advertising networks — that keep the sites operational and making money.
She works to identify all of the companies that are supporting a site hosting illegal content, along with their contact information — pressure points on an industry that she says is too callous to act.
Li tells victims she will never stop fighting to get their images off the internet. But she is careful not to offer them any guarantees. “We can’t promise that things will come down,” she said. “That’s not the reality.”
Even failure, Li believes, has a purpose. She can use evidence that the options for victims are not working to push for new laws.
“People think the internet is this celestial realm where laws cannot be enforced,” Li said. “No, the internet is terrestrial. It’s people going into buildings every day and making decisions. … There’s a lot we can do that’s still on the table.”


